Take a Pebble, by Emerson, Lake and Palmer

At the end of 1969 Greg Lake was ready to move on from King Crimson. He knew Robert Fripp back from their teenage days in Dorset, were they took lessons from the same guitar teacher. There was a musical and personal chemistry between the two, a unique bond that Lake talked about in an interview for New Musical Express in February 1971: “With Bob and I, it’s like I have something he needs, and he has something I need. He has will power and stay power which I lack and I have a sort of spontaneous energy which he lacks. I lived with Fripp when I was with Crimso and I don’t think anybody else in the world could live with Fripp, or me for that matter.”  The band as he knew it was no more when Michael Giles and Ian McDonald decided to quit after the US tour that took place between October and December of 1969 and culminated in several shows at the Fillmore West in San Francisco. Fripp wanted to continue with a rotating crew of musicians, Lake wanted a long lasting band. In an interesting alignment of the stars Lake met Keith Emerson at that Fillmore West show, headlined by the Chambers Brothers with King Crimson and The Nice acting as supporting bands. Keith Emerson also reached an impasse with his band The Nice and the two saw a future together. Emerson wanted to continue the trio format that worked so well for The Nice and the picture was completed with Carl Palmer, who came through a recommendation from manager-supreme Robert Stigwood.

ELP’s first album is usually not considered their top achievement. That rank is reserved to Brain Salad Surgery, Tarkus or Pictures at an Exhibition. However I have a soft spot for it, maybe because it is such an amazing debut by three excellent musicians, who although they never played together before, manage to sound so cohesive while playing complex music. The album did well after the band got its exposure in the Isle of Wight festival in August 1970. It reached the top 4 in the UK album chart and the top 20 in the Billboard LP chart.

I always liked the lyrical side of ELP, even though with all the bombastic music they made it became difficult to find these moments. That pan of their music came usually from Greg Lake’s contributions. Lake already demonstrated his skill for melody in King Crimson’s debut, writing the melody lines for Epitaph and In The Court Of The Crimson King, plus the riff for 21st Century Schizoid Man. Some of ELP’s most enduring moments are the songs Lake wrote such as Lucky Man, Sage, From the Beginning and Still…. You Turn Me On. Take A Pebble is a great showcase of Lake’s songwriting, singing and guitar playing. In a November 1970 Melody Maker article he said about the song: “I wrote this after Christmas with Keith when there were just the two of us and Carl hadn’t joined us. It started out as a folk guitar thing, then Keith added piano and I used a bass. The solos weren’t there to start with but Keith wrote a solo and I decided to put in a guitar solo as well. It was a solo I had written about five years ago and never had a chance to use before.” Lake used to play a Gibson Jumbo guitar in the early days, then adding Martin guitars to his arsenal. His acoustic guitar work and sound always provided a great segue from Emerson’s Hammond, church organ or Moog solos into a calm, serene place.

Many keyboard players have contributed great compositions, arrangements and solos to the canon of progressive rock over the years, but no one symbolized the virtuosic side of that genre as Keith Emerson. A trailblazer in the use of synthesizers in rock music and a one-man lab for Robert Moog, he experimented with those machines when they still had a physical element to them and had to be patched with cords and tinkered with while performing live on stage.


Keith Emerson with the Moog

I decided not to pick one of his synth solos (from the debut album Lucky Man would have been an obvious choice), but a song that features him on piano. Emerson is famous for his abilities on amplified keyboards, but his piano playing is no less interesting and virtuosic. His early recordings with the Nice and on Emerson, Lake and Palmer’s early recordings featured him often with a trio playing acoustic instruments, proving that progressive rock is not about guitar and keyboard gizmos, but about the musicianship. The unique sound at the opening of the song is created by plucking the piano strings with a guitar pick.


Keith Emerson upside down

Chris Welch of Melody Maker visited ELP in in the studio in 1970 during rehearsals for their debut album. When he asked them to play something, Greg responded: “Well, there’s not a lot to choose from”. In Welch’s words: “They played a beautiful number called Pebbles which sounded like a rock-MJQ, with Carl on the brushes, Keith on piano and Greg singing in a rich, warm style”. Comparing that number to the Modern Jazz Quartet is actually not a bad comparison. Before the knives, stage gymnastics and revolving pianos, here is Take a Pebble from ELP’s first record, released in 1970.

Just take a pebble and cast it to the sea,

Then watch the ripples that unfold into me

My face spills so gently into your eyes

Disturbing the waters of our lives


Shreds of our memories are lying on your grass

Wounded words of laughter are graveyards of the past

Photographs are grey and torn, scattered in your fields

Letters of your memories are not real


Wear sadness on your shoulders like a worn-out overcoat

In pockets creased and tattered hang the rags of your hopes

The daybreak is your midnight, the colours have all died

Disturbing the waters of our lives,

Of our lives, of our lives, lives, lives, lives

Of our lives

Categories: Songs

Tagged as: , , ,

3 replies »

Leave a Reply